Alcohol Vs Alcohol-Free Hand Sanitisers

April 13, 2020 3 min read

Alcohol Vs Alcohol-Free Hand Sanitisers

With the arrival of the novel coronavirus and flu season on the horizon here in New Zealand, interest in hand sanitisers has reached an all-time high. Naturally, heightened demand leads to heightened curiosity about the effectiveness of available options. For many, this means choosing between an alcohol-based or alcohol-free hand sanitiser spray.

The World Health Organisation (WHO) recommends sanitisers with high alcohol content for its potency and immediacy, but there are good reasons to stop and compare those alcohol-based chemical sanitisers with the unique benefits offered by alcohol-free hand sanitisers. We look at some of the key differences below.

What’s the difference between alcohol-based & alcohol-free sanitisers?

Alcohol-based hand sanitisers are highly concentrated, often more than 60% alcohol. Alcohol has a very low boiling point so the heat of your hands, along with the heat generated by friction from rubbing them together, is enough to rapidly evaporate the alcohol, taking the germs with it, chemically killing nearly 100% of germs in as little as 15 seconds. This means that alcohol-based sanitisers work quickly but briefly. The rapid evaporation of the alcohol, however, often takes with it moisture from your skin, which can leave your hands feeling rather dry.

Alcohol-free hand sanitisers are primarily water, with a low, gentle concentration of an active ingredient. Usually fragrance-free and alcohol-free sanitisers kill germs with a layer of molecules that provide lasting protection, warding off germs for hours. Unlike alcohol-based sanitisers, which offer an immediate chemical kill of germs, alcohol-free sanitisers offer fast-acting but enduring physical protection against germs, including over 100 known microbes like E. coli, norovirus, and Ebola.

What is the active ingredient in alcohol-free sanitisers?

The effectiveness of alcohol-based hand sanitisers is not in question, but their effectiveness compared to alcohol-free sanitisers remains somewhat inconclusive. This is because alcohol-free sanitisers do not all use the same active ingredient, yielding inconsistent results. What’s more, comparison tests often assess their immediate effectiveness, rather than the duration of their protection.

New Edition NZ's range of hand sanitiser sprays are 99% water-based and use only a single active ingredient: Quaternary Ammonium Compound (QAC). QAC is a molecule derived from sand and through a synthetic process it activates, enabling it to form a strong bond on surfaces, physically kill germ molecules as they come in contact with it, and offer this protection for a much longer period of time than alcohol-based alternatives. This ingredient is entirely safe for human contact, which is demonstrated by its presence in other health and beauty formulas such as toothpaste, contact lens solutions, cosmetics, shampoos, certain antibacterial soaps, wet wipes, deodorants, and skin antiseptics and medications.

The benefits of alcohol-free hand sanitisers

The biggest advantage of alcohol-free hand sanitisers is the lasting protection they offer. While alcohol-based sanitisers work for seconds, chemically killing only germs that were already present, an alcohol-free solution like New Edition NZ’s forms a protective barrier that physically kills and protects against germs for up to 24 hours. What’s more, it won’t dry out your skin and is gentle enough to use on even newborn babies. It is, in fact, less toxic than even Vitamin C or coffee!!

New Edition NZ’s Sanitiser Range is made right here in New Zealand and contains no harsh chemicals. It is fragrance-free and protects against 99% of germs.

Choose a sanitiser you can use on the whole family

Should you decide that alcohol-free is the way to go, at New Edition NZ we offer a range of products to meet your needs. Buy hand sanitisers your whole family can use, with home and travel options too!

If you're after more information about the New Edition NZ Sanitiser technology, learn more here


Leave a comment

Comments will be approved before showing up.


Also in The Journal

Q & A with our New Edition NZ Pumpd product designers, Chris & Jono
Q & A with our New Edition NZ Pumpd product designers, Chris & Jono

June 03, 2020 3 min read

Chris & Jono are the ones charged with turning our product ideas into reality!⁠ We chatted to both designers about some of the special design elements that make Pumpd stand out from other breast pumps on the market....



Read More
Being Mum: Bec Whitley
Being Mum: Bec Whitley

May 15, 2020 7 min read

Meet Bec, self-confessed “Accidental #mumblogger”, wife and mum to two beautiful children, George and Sadie. Well known in mama circles as being refreshingly honest, very real and instantly lovable. 

Read More
Q & A with New Edition NZ Founder, Danielle Robinson
Q & A with New Edition NZ Founder, Danielle Robinson

May 13, 2020 3 min read

Dani, the founder and Director of New Edition NZ, is passionate about sharing our story as a New Zealand made brand while creating products to help caregivers feel connected and supported.

Read More
plus minus cross arrow-left arrow-right arrow-bottom cart dropdown-arrow next previous heart search tick amazon-payment amex bitcoin cirrus diners-club discover dk dogecoin facebook fancy forbrugsforeningen apple-pay google-plus instagram interact jcb litecoin maestrooo mastercard paypal pinterest stripe tumblr twitter vimeo rss visa youtube lock video-play happy sleepy wink-left wink-left wink-left buff green